Table of Contents

Alt Image Text
Photorealistic Houston courthouse scene illustrating burdens of proof, with a defense attorney and adult client on white courthouse steps and a lawful outer-clothing pat-down near red and blue police light bokeh, representing reasonable suspicion and probable cause in Texas.
Featured
Do not index
Authors
Sub-item
In the legal system, there are various
standards or burdens of proof. Meaning, how strong the evidence needs to be for
police to stop a citizen, evidence to obtain a warrant, evidence to win a civil
lawsuit, evidence to terminate a parent’s rights and ultimately, how strong the
evidence needs to be to take someone’s freedom and liberty. It is a ladder of the strength of evidence
needed in each of these scenarios.
The burden of proof is always on the
person who brings a claim in a dispute.
Reasonable Suspicion
Reasonable suspicion is a legal standard that applies in different criminal-law contexts, most often where searches and seizures are involved. It requires that officers have an objectively reasonable basis for suspecting criminal activity before detaining someone. In addition, before conducting a pat-down, officers must reasonably suspect that a subject is armed and dangerous. Officers can, however, ask people to stop and answer questions without reasonable suspicion.
When an officer conducts a “pat-down,” they are
only allowed to pat the outer clothing. During a pat-down, officers are feeling
for anything that could be used to harm the officer, such as a knife or gun. Officers
are not allowed to go into a person’s pockets without permission or consent
from that person, a search warrant or if the person is under arrest and the
search is “incident to arrest.” So, if an officer feels a soft, plastic baggy
inside someone’s pocket during a pat-down, that is not enough to legally go
into the person’s pocket.
Probable
Cause
In United States law, probable cause is the standard by which police authorities have reason to obtain a warrant for the arrest of a suspected criminal or the issuing of a search warrant. It is also the standard by which grand juries issue criminal indictments. The principle behind the standard is to limit the power of authorities to perform random or abusive searches (unlawful search and seizure) and to promote lawful evidence gathering and procedural form during criminal arrest and prosecution. The standard also applies to personal or property searches.
The right of the people to be secure in
their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and
seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon
probable cause , supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly
describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.
Clear
and Convincing Evidence
Clear and
convincing proof means that the evidence presented by a party during the trial
must be highly and substantially more probable to be true than not and the
trier of fact must have a firm belief or conviction in its factuality. In
this standard, a greater degree of believability must be met than the common
standard of proof in civil actions, which only requires that the facts as a
threshold be more likely than not to prove the issue for which they are
asserted.
This is the
standard applied in family court when there is an action to terminate a
parent’s rights.
When
discussing the ladder of burdens of proof in jury selection during a criminal
trial, I often ask jurors, “How sure would you want the evidence to be before
someone could strip you of your parental rights?” The answer is always “Damn
sure.” Then I turn to the even higher burden in criminal courts, Beyond a
Reasonable Doubt.
Beyond a Reasonable Doubt
The law says
we cannot put a legal definition on Beyond a Reasonable Doubt, as it is
personal for each person.
However, this
is the highest standard used as the burden of proof and typically only applies
in criminal proceedings. If there is a real doubt, based upon reason and common
sense after careful and impartial consideration of all the evidence, or lack of
evidence, in a case, then the level of proof has not been met.
Proof beyond a
reasonable doubt, therefore, is proof of such a convincing character that one
would be willing to rely and act upon it without hesitation in the most
important of one’s own affairs. However, it does not mean an absolute
certainty. The standard that must be met by the prosecution’s evidence in a
criminal prosecution is that no other logical explanation can be derived from
the facts except that the defendant committed the crime, thereby overcoming the
presumption that a person is innocent
unless and until proven guilty.
The main
reason that this high level of proof is demanded in criminal trials is that
such proceedings can result in the deprivation of a defendant’s liberty or even
in his or her death. These outcomes are far more severe than in civil trials,
in which monetary damages are the common remedy.
It is important to note that “Beyond a
Reasonable Doubt” is not beyond a shadow of a doubt. If someone knew 100% what
happened in a criminal case, then they would likely be a witness in the case
and therefore unable to sit as a juror.
Scroll to the bottom for every post in this series.


