Table of Contents

Alt Image Text
Adult suspect and defense attorney in profile near an unmarked patrol car outside a Houston courthouse at dusk, illustrating Miranda warnings and custodial interrogation in Texas.
Featured
Do not index
Authors
Sub-item
Miranda Warnings
If only we had a dollar for every time a new client called
about a recent arrest and told us, “…and they never read me my Miranda Rights!”
We
understand that when clients come to us they are desperately looking for ways
to get their cases dismissed. Oftentimes, clients feel like not having had
their Miranda Warnings given to them
is a way to get their case dismissed. Let us spend some time on this subject
for a better understanding.
Despite what is seen on television, the Miranda warnings only come into play
during a custodial interrogation . If a defendant is in custody and being
questioned by law enforcement, the defendant should have been told his/her
rights – Miranda warnings.
The
purpose is to put the suspect on notice that prior to answering any questions
from law enforcement, the suspect has certain rights that he or she can invoke
or waive. This protects an individual in custody from making self-incriminating
statements instead of invoking their 5 th Amendment right – “I’ll
take the 5 th !” It also protects an individual’s 6 th
Amendment right to counsel.
Typically, the warnings read are:
You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can be
used against you in court. You have the right to talk to a lawyer for advice
before we ask you any questions. You have the right to have a lawyer with you
during questioning. If you cannot afford a lawyer, one will be appointed for
you before any questioning if you wish. If you decide to answer questions now
without a lawyer present, you have the right to stop answering at any time.
The warning is
deemed adequate as long as the defendant’s rights are properly disclosed such
that any waiver of those rights by the defendant is knowing, voluntary, and
intelligent.
If a
client is not free to leave, that is considered being in “custody.” It gets a
little tricky because prior to being “detained,” police officers can freely ask
investigative questions such as, “Where are you coming from?” “Where are you
going?” “Do you know how fast you were going?” “How much have you had to drink
tonight?”
A
citizen is free to answer or free to not answer these questions, but we suggest
that folks always be polite to law enforcement.
Once the officer has made a decision to detain a citizen (person does
not feel free to leave) then any questions asked of the citizen by law
enforcement would be subject to Miranda .
So,
if someone is pulled over on traffic, the person answers the investigatory
questions by the officer and then the officer later chooses to detain the
person upon the conclusion of their investigation, if it is a quiet patrol ride
to the station and the person does not make any incriminating statements in
response to law enforcement’s questioning, then Miranda does not apply. If
the person chooses to volunteer self-incriminating statements, but the
statements were not in response to anything the police asked the person, Miranda does not apply.
So,
just because someone was arrested and never given Miranda warnings that does not mean the case will be dismissed.
This
week JL Carpenter was a guest on Christopher Jordan’s podcast Dudes N Beer
discussing 4 th Amendment rights.
If
you missed it, you can hear it through this link:
Scroll to the bottom for every post in this series.
Finally,
tomorrow is that Hallmark holiday – Valentine’s Day. We got nothing but love for our clients!
Everyone enjoy their day and make good choices, but if things don’t go as
planned, “Don’t go to jail, Call JL!”


