JL Carpenter on The Price of Business Discussing Netflix’s “The Murdaugh Murders,”

When a true-crime series takes over the conversation, people in Houston, Harris County, and across Texas often ask the same question: *Could something like that happen here, and how would a Texas criminal case really work?* I understand why. These shows make criminal investigations look fast, dr

JL Carpenter on The Price of Business Discussing Netflix’s “The Murdaugh Murders,”
Cover
murdaugh-murders-texas-criminal-defense-houston.png
OG Image
murdaugh-murders-texas-criminal-defense-houston.png
Alt Image Text
Houston criminal defense attorney and adult client on white courthouse steps at dusk, illustrating Murdaugh Murders commentary and Texas criminal defense procedure.
Featured
Do not index
Authors
Parent item
Sub-item

JL Carpenter on The Price of Business Discussing Netflix’s “The Murdaugh Murders,”

When a true-crime series takes over the conversation, people in Houston, Harris County, and across Texas often ask the same question: Could something like that happen here, and how would a Texas criminal case really work? I understand why. These shows make criminal investigations look fast, dramatic, and obvious. Real life is messier. As a former prosecutor and now a criminal defense attorney serving Greater Houston, I watch cases like Netflix’s The Murdaugh Murders through a different lens: how law enforcement builds a case, how prosecutors present it, and where the defense must test every assumption. If you have been following this story as part of the broader world of true-crime coverage and commentary, this post will help you separate television storytelling from what actually matters in a Texas courtroom.
💡
Scroll to the bottom for every post in this series.

Why This Case Resonates So Strongly In Houston And Across Texas

There is a reason a series like The Murdaugh Murders gets people talking. It combines privilege, family tragedy, public suspicion, and questions about whether the system treats some people differently. Those themes hit home in Harris County, Galveston County, Fort Bend County, and Brazoria County because Texans see every day that criminal cases are not decided by headlines. They are decided by evidence, procedure, witness credibility, and whether the State can prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
That distinction matters. In Texas, a person accused of a crime is presumed innocent, and the State carries the burden of proof. Texas criminal procedure also gives the defense important tools to inspect the State’s evidence under Texas Code of Criminal Procedure art. 39.14, commonly called the Michael Morton Act. That discovery process is a major part of how a defense lawyer tests whether the dramatic narrative the public has heard actually lines up with the facts.

What True-Crime Shows Usually Get Right

To be fair, true-crime documentaries often capture a few things accurately.

The State Builds A Story From Fragments

Most serious cases are built from pieces: phone data, timelines, witness statements, financial records, forensic reports, and post-offense behavior. That is true in Texas just as it is anywhere else. Jurors often hear a case presented as a sequence of small facts that prosecutors say point in one direction.
In a homicide case in Texas, prosecutors may pursue charges ranging from murder under Texas Penal Code § 19.02 to capital murder under § 19.03, depending on the alleged facts. Lesser homicide-related charges can include manslaughter under § 19.04 and criminally negligent homicide under § 19.05. The exact charge matters because intent, mental state, and surrounding circumstances matter.

Conduct After The Incident Can Become Its Own Issue

One reason true-crime audiences focus on “cover-ups” is that post-incident conduct can create separate criminal exposure. In Texas, allegations about hiding or altering evidence can implicate tampering with physical evidence under Texas Penal Code § 37.09. Allegations about helping someone avoid arrest can raise issues under hindering apprehension or prosecution, § 38.05. Those are not side notes. They can become major parts of how the State frames motive and consciousness of guilt.

Public Image And Private Facts Often Clash

Documentaries also correctly show how fast the public can form opinions. Someone may look polished, connected, or sympathetic on camera. None of that answers the legal question. In court, image is not evidence. Or at least it is not supposed to be.

What True-Crime Shows Usually Get Wrong

This is where I think viewers in Houston and throughout Texas need to slow down.

They Compress Time

A Netflix series may package months or years into a few episodes. Real felony cases in Harris County district courts or Galveston County courts do not move like that. There are bond proceedings, discovery review, forensic testing, witness interviews, pretrial motions, hearings on admissibility, and often long stretches where a defense lawyer is doing careful work that never makes good television.
Under current Texas law, bail decisions must be made without unnecessary delay and generally no later than 48 hours after arrest under Texas Code of Criminal Procedure art. 17.028. The court must make an individualized decision and impose the least restrictive conditions necessary to reasonably assure appearance and safety, while considering the factors listed in art. 17.15. That is a legal process, not a dramatic montage.

They Blur Suspicion And Proof

A viewer may come away thinking, “There are too many coincidences.” But coincidences are not enough. Suspicion is not enough. Bad behavior is not always proof of the charged offense. In my work, one of the most important things I do is force the State to prove each element of the offense it filed, not just invite the jury to dislike the accused.
That matters in any serious Texas case, whether the allegation is murder, assault, intoxication manslaughter, or tampering with evidence. For example, an assault charge in Texas depends on the precise conduct alleged under Texas Penal Code § 22.01, and aggravated assault depends on additional facts under § 22.02. The details drive the law.

They Understate The Defense Investigation

On television, the defense is often shown reacting. In real life, a good defense is proactive. My office looks for missing evidence, inconsistent statements, timeline problems, digital evidence issues, forensic weaknesses, and alternative explanations. As a former prosecutor, I know where the government tends to feel confident and where it may be overreaching.
In Texas, discovery under art. 39.14 gives the defense broad access to offense reports, witness statements, documents, recorded statements, photographs, and tangible evidence in the State’s possession, subject to statutory limits. That is not glamorous, but it is where many cases are won or lost.

How A Texas Prosecutor Would Approach A Case Like This

If a similar high-profile allegation landed in Houston, the Harris County District Attorney’s Office would work to build a coherent theory supported by physical evidence, digital evidence, witness testimony, and motive. Law enforcement agencies such as the Houston Police Department, Harris County Sheriff’s Office, or Texas DPS may each play roles depending on jurisdiction and the nature of the investigation.
From the prosecution side, the goal is usually to answer these questions:

Can The State Prove Identity?

Who actually committed the act? This is often the first battlefield. Prosecutors want surveillance, phone records, location data, eyewitnesses, admissions, forensic evidence, or some combination of those things.

Can The State Prove Intent?

In Texas, homicide charges are separated in large part by mental state. Did the State have evidence of intentional or knowing conduct for murder under § 19.02? Or did the facts fit recklessness for manslaughter under § 19.04? These are not minor distinctions. They are the core of the case.

Can The State Explain Away The Gaps?

Every major case has gaps. Good prosecutors try to frame those gaps as unimportant. Good defense lawyers make the jury sit with them.

Can The State Keep Damaging Evidence In?

Pretrial litigation matters. Prosecutors want statements, digital records, and forensic testimony admitted. The defense may challenge searches, seizures, statements, chain of custody, relevance, prejudice, or scientific reliability depending on the facts.

How The Defense Should Respond In A Houston-Area Serious Felony Case

If you or your family is watching a headline case and wondering what a real defense looks like in Texas, here is the answer: methodical pressure on every part of the State’s proof.

Start With Silence

If police want to “hear your side,” be careful. In Texas, statements become evidence. People talk because they think they can clear things up. Too often, they give the State details it did not previously have, or they make small inaccuracies that prosecutors later argue show guilt. If officers from HPD, the Harris County Sheriff’s Office, or another agency contact you, do not try to explain your way out of it without counsel.

Secure Discovery And Preserve Evidence

The defense should move quickly to obtain discovery under art. 39.14, preserve texts, call logs, social media records, surveillance footage, receipts, vehicle data, and witness information. Time matters. Evidence disappears fast.

Challenge The Theory, Not Just The Details

Sometimes the most effective defense is not arguing over one witness or one exhibit. It is showing that the State’s whole theory depends on assumptions stacked on assumptions. A polished narrative may fall apart when you test timing, access, motive, or forensic interpretation.

Address Bail And Pretrial Release Early

A person accused of a serious crime in Texas may face steep bond conditions. But bail is supposed to be individualized, not automatic. Articles 17.028 and 17.15 matter here. In Harris County, whether a case is filed as a felony or misdemeanor affects where it starts procedurally. The Harris County District Clerk notes that district courts hear felony cases, while county criminal courts at law hear Class A and B misdemeanors, with criminal courts operating at the Harris County Criminal Justice Center, 1201 Franklin Street, Houston. See the District Clerk’s criminal court information here.

Why Media Attention Can Hurt A Fair Trial

This is one of the biggest lessons from any famous true-crime story. The louder the coverage, the easier it is for people to confuse repetition with proof.
In a place as large as Houston, news can still spread fast, especially online. Family members read comments. Witnesses watch clips. Potential jurors absorb narratives before they ever hear sworn testimony. That is why defense work in a public case requires discipline. A lawyer cannot try the case on social media. The real work happens in motions, investigation, hearings, and trial preparation.
Texas law also recognizes deadlines and procedural protections that often get lost in public discussion. For example, if a defendant is detained and the State is not ready for trial within certain timelines, Texas Code of Criminal Procedure art. 17.151 can become relevant. And if no indictment or information is timely presented under certain circumstances, Chapter 32 may matter. Those are not television moments, but they are real protections.

What Houston Readers Should Take Away From “The Murdaugh Murders”

If you are a viewer, the right takeaway is not “I know who is guilty.” The better takeaway is this: criminal cases are built on narratives, and narratives must be tested.
That is especially important in Texas, where charges can carry life-changing consequences. A murder allegation, a felony assault allegation, or an accusation of tampering with evidence can affect liberty, family relationships, employment, firearm rights, and reputation. Even if a case does not end in a conviction, public records can still create long-term damage. Texas DPS maintains the state criminal history repository, and DPS explains that deferred adjudication and conviction records may be public in many circumstances, while expunction and nondisclosure are governed by specific Texas laws and court orders. See DPS resources on criminal history records and crime records FAQs.
For some people, post-case relief may involve Chapter 55A of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure on expunction or Government Code Chapter 411, Subchapter E-1 on nondisclosure. But eligibility is highly fact-specific, and many serious offenses are excluded. This is one reason I tell people not to think only about trial. You also have to think about the long-term record consequences from day one.

My View As A Former Prosecutor Now Defending The Accused In Texas

When I discuss a story like The Murdaugh Murders, I am not interested in adding to the noise. I am interested in helping people understand what the public often misses.
I know how prosecutors evaluate witness statements, how they use circumstantial evidence, and how they try to present a seamless timeline. I also know those cases can be challenged. Witnesses can be mistaken. Evidence can be incomplete. Timelines can be overstated. Forensic conclusions can be narrower than the State suggests. And sometimes panic, addiction, family conflict, or bad decisions after the fact get treated as if they prove the charged offense, when they may not.
That is why criminal defense matters so much in Harris County, Galveston County, Fort Bend County, and Brazoria County. The system works only if someone is willing to push back hard, demand the records, test the assumptions, and hold the State to its burden.

Final Thoughts For Houston And Harris County Readers

Netflix can tell a gripping story. A prosecutor can tell a compelling story too. But in Texas, especially in courts serving Houston and Harris County, the question is not which story is more emotional. The question is whether the State can prove every required element under Texas law with admissible, reliable evidence.
If you are under investigation, have been arrested, or believe law enforcement is building a case against you, do not wait for the narrative to harden around you. Do not assume you can talk your way out of it. Do not assume the police, the Harris County District Attorney, or any investigating agency already has the full picture right.
My office represents people throughout Greater Houston, including Harris, Galveston, Fort Bend, and Brazoria Counties. If you need straight answers about a serious Texas criminal case, call before you speak to investigators or make the situation harder than it already is.
If you or a loved one is facing criminal charges anywhere in Greater Houston, don't go to jail — call J.L. Call the Law Office of J.L. Carpenter at (713) 201-6767 or schedule your consultation today.

Don't Face Life's Most Challenging Moments Alone

Schedule Your Consultation Now!
<!-- Google Tag Manager (noscript) --> <noscript><iframe src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html?id=GTM-KHNLTCHV" height="0" width="0" style="display:none;visibility:hidden"></iframe></noscript> <!-- End Google Tag Manager (noscript) -->